kai1275 wrote:
Her face is a 3.5 to a 4 at best and that is being nice, when you pointed out that under-bite, I had not even bothered to dig that deep into why her face is lacking. Her midsection does not look too good either, but some of that could be shirt folds in a funny position or the sloppy parts after just having a baby or something, I dunno. The chest to stomach ratio is still poor and like someone else said, those lanky arms and shoulders are not attractive either. The Dwight Howard style dimensions are not sexy on women, unlike men. She even looks to be lacking in good nutrition as well but that can be reversed in many ways. You and Winston can fool each other with your unorthodox/unique beauty grading, but on a mainstream scale, no one else here is buying it. I personally don't give a shit what you guys like fetish wise or whatever, but don't promote something that is the exact opposite of general consensus and tell others they are crazy or wrong when they say the exact opposite.
I know there are many hard-asses on HA, that trash all women's looks regardless, but no one reasonable is going to grade Dianne anywhere near an 8. That is just simply absurd. Don't piss on our backs and tell us it's raining.
Your rating of Dianne seems very harsh! Looks and ratings should be normally distributed with average falling at 5.5. If there are no 10s, then the average falls to 5. To keep things simple, let's just consider facial attractiveness. So never mind that Dianne is relatively tall with long legs in Phils. which definitely gets her points with guys there.
Average looking is generally neutral, not attractive nor repulsive. As you go below 5, the repulsiveness starts to kick-in and as you move up from 5, the person starts to attract you more and more.
Check-out this chart of mostly white girls to see what I mean.
http://i.imgur.com/hCbua.jpg
Since it's a normal type distribution, by the time you get down to the 3 level, its fairly uncommon and the samples are quite ugly. No way can Dianne be 3.5!
Consider the kiss test. Imagine kissing the girl. If it's repulsive, she's below average, if its something you might enjoy, she's above average, and if you are totally neutral about it, she's probably sitting at around average to your tastes at least.
I don't see how you can consider Dianne repulsive. I just don't see it. To me, she's mildly attractive face wise so at least a 5.5. Perhaps better than that depending on how her weight is (heavier would fill out her face and make her look a bit more youthful) and how she does her hair, etc.
I also don't see how you can consider Winston more attractive than her. Even back when he was close to her age, I think they would have been reasonably matched.